This interesting comment on my preceding post, from
That Nerdy Girl Who Is Skinny, seems to have mysteriously disappeared. I hereby
reproduce it:
The prominence of French takes another degree of
importance when the process of language attrition is taken into account.
Language attrition happens when a speaker
becomes more exposed to a language than another or certain words over others.
Eventually, the most used language and vocabulary starts affecting the use of
the lesser used languages and vocabulary by causing word retrieval problems and
structural changes. This happens because the brain is plastic and reorganizes
itself to make the most used language and vocabulary easier to access. This
happens at the cost of making the lesser used languages and vocabulary harder to
access. Language attrition, like language acquisition, is a matter of
EXPOSITION and USE.
L1 attrition is often seen in bi(tri,
etc)linguals and especially in people who move abroad and don't get to use
their L1 often.
The most blatant manifestation of language
attrition we can see here is Frenglish speakers. Next time you converse with a
Frenglish speaker, ask them to redo the whole sentence in French and watch them
struggle to retrieve the proper words even though French is their L1. Frenglish
speakers foster Frenglish speakers by increasing and solidifying the EXPOSITION
and the USE of English words over their French counterpart. That's aside from
the fact that the rules of communication dictate that to be understood, 2
people have to use the same code, which encourages further the use of Frenglish
among Frenglish speakers. That's why, dozens of years later, we still use English
terminology for all things mechanic and tools. It has become harder to
understand what people refer to when they use the French terminology for those
things. Again, a matter of exposition.
Over generations, this causes permanent language
loss.
So where does French prominence on signs come
into play? It's about exposition. French prominence on signs ensures that
French is the language the most readily seen and as such, increases the chances
that it will be the one used. People want a name for things, they will pick the
first thing they see, because people are lazy. That's how we got English
speakers to use "Dépanneur" over "Convenience store" ;)
– That
Nerdy Girl Who Is Skinny
No comments:
Post a Comment